1 Microsoft Project and Planner plans
Best for microsoft 365 organizations that want one vendor
For an organization that has standardized on Microsoft, the case is one vendor, one agreement, and project plans from the same company that supplies the mail and files your people already use. Planner Plan 1 covers task dependencies, a Timeline view, reports and backlogs, and Plan 3 adds the Project desktop app, baselines and critical path. Both are priced per user and paid yearly.
Watch for. Microsoft states that an annual commitment is required for administrators buying online. Monthly purchase is available to other users at a higher rate.
- How it charges
- Per user, paid yearly, or monthly at a higher rate
- Main limit
- Plan 1 shows portfolios view-only, full resource tools start at Plan 3
2 Custom build by Black Badger
Best for microsoft shops whose process the Project plans do not fit
Standardizing on Microsoft does not oblige you to run projects in a Microsoft product. A custom system can use Microsoft sign-in and sit beside the mail, calendars and files your teams already have. Black Badger, which publishes this guide, builds it around your own intake, approvals and resource rules, which is why it ranks second here. There is no per-user project license to assign, and you own the code and the accounts.
Watch for. Someone on your side should own the system after launch, the way someone owns your Microsoft tenant today. Discovery and a written scope come first.
- How it charges
- One-time build scoped in writing, then running costs such as hosting
- Main limit
- Needs a scoping call first, and suits companies of 50 or more employees
What a custom build involves, and how to ask about one
3 Smartsheet
Best for microsoft organizations where projects live in Excel today
Smartsheet ranks third for Microsoft organizations, and the reason is habit. A great deal of enterprise project tracking still happens in spreadsheets, and Smartsheet is the product that looks most like one while adding Gantt and approvals. SAML single sign-on is listed as an Enterprise addition, so people can use the corporate sign-in you already manage. It ranks below the Project plans because it is a second vendor.
Watch for. Single sign-on is not on Business. If corporate sign-in is a requirement, you are buying Enterprise by quote.
- How it charges
- Per member, billed yearly or monthly, Enterprise quoted
- Main limit
- Pro stops at 10 members and 250 automations a month, no API calls
4 Planview
Best for microsoft organizations that need a separate portfolio layer
Planview is fourth. Large Microsoft organizations often keep scheduling in Microsoft tools and look elsewhere for the portfolio layer above it, and Planview is the vendor that sells strategic portfolio management as its main business. It ranks here and not higher because it is a second major vendor with no published price, and the selection is a formal one.
Watch for. Ask how the Planview product you choose would exchange data with your Microsoft plans. Nothing on the pages we read answers that.
- How it charges
- Quoted by sales, no published price
- Main limit
- No public price or plan limits, every figure needs a sales quote
5 Asana
Best for business units that want a lighter tool under corporate IT
Asana ranks fifth for a Microsoft organization. It is usually chosen by business units that find scheduling tools heavier than they need, and corporate IT can still govern it, because SAML authentication and SCIM user provisioning are listed as Enterprise features. It sits below Planview on this list because it overlaps with what Planner Plan 1 already gives a Microsoft customer for task-level work.
Watch for. SAML and SCIM need the Enterprise plan, which is priced through sales and not on the pricing page.
- How it charges
- Per user, billed yearly or monthly, Enterprise quoted
- Main limit
- Portfolios need Advanced, resource tools and SSO need Enterprise
6 ClickUp
Best for teams that want docs and chat inside the project tool
ClickUp is sixth here. Its pitch is one tool for tasks, docs and chat, and an organization standardized on Microsoft already has tools for the last two. That overlap is why it ranks last for this question. Where a division does choose it, the Enterprise plan lists SAML single sign-on and SCIM provisioning, so accounts can follow your directory.
Watch for. Below Enterprise the API is limited to 100 calls a minute, which matters if you plan to sync with other systems.
- How it charges
- Per user, billed yearly, Enterprise quoted
- Main limit
- API limit is 100 calls a minute until Enterprise, then 10,000